I am not trying to sound smart, and I can’t really speak Latin. The expression is simply the standard term for a logical error. In vernacular, it means “after that, hence because of that,” as most of you know. It is common for humans to draw causal connections from temporal sequences. In my field, substance use and addiction, "gateway theory," based on the same fallacy, has ruled over research and policy. Hardly anybody cared that it does not matter which drug one starts with for the risk of poisoning or addiction. But it's not just that the false causes are used as guides for action. Once they are in play, the true causes are ignored.
Does anybody doubt Trump would win, hands down, over Biden if not for the Chinese virus? He almost did (or has won) despite the Democrat agitprop that spread the calumny of the virus deaths' being Trump's fault. Nobody cared that Trump's trump card was economics, his China trade measures were substantial part of its success, and the virus came from China smack at the good time to destroy Trump's advantage. The progressive media (a clear redundancy) ignored China's role in the spread of the virus, while Trump was depicted as a Plague-time well-poisoner.
What is the connection between the China virus and Biden's creeping out of his basement to possible presidency, with his pothead sidekick aiming at the Resolute Desk? All that was thanks to the common human mistake of readily taking “after that” for “because of that”, Trump's presidency—hence COVID deaths, the false conclusion endlessly propagated by Democrats and their media, exactly the "Organs" of the Democrat Party, as their counterparts used to be honestly called in the Soviet Union. Who cares that those deaths have no relationship whatsoever with Trump, who has done the maximum he could to withstand the biological attack while fighting the sabotage of Democrat governors, the posturing of know-nothing buffoons from NIH and WHO, and the constant attempts of political assassination from the Democrat Congress and Biden's "xenophobia" accusations. The NY governor Cuomo has actively murdered seniors by his order for care facilities—nobody will charge him with the crime. It is Trump who bears its consequences. Who cares that the US, despite all the Democrat agitprop, is far from the worst corona-wise in the world. It’s Trump's fault just because he was the president when it happened—forget all the praises Cuomo has given him in a fit of honesty.
Forget that it has been and would still be Trump's team that has born the brunt of the Chinese biological attack—and this is what it is. Even if—and it's a big if—the virus were not cooked in that Wuhan "institute," it was definitely deliberately spread to kill the US economy and thus remove Trump, the enemy of China. The Democrat fifth column was only happy to help, busy with the same work ever since Trump had been elected. Those are the causes ignored. Forget what is at stake: America’s freedom, energy independence, peace, Middle East conciliation, trade fairness, and honesty with allies and enemies. Let’s just pray that the utopia that this country has been does not turn into another nightmare of the communist takeover and bread lines. That has been a true cause-effect relationship.
The party that fought for slavery, that has revived racial conflict in this country and supports pogroms, that has open antisemites as its vocal and unrestrained leaders, that has given Iran billions to fund world-wide terror and pave its way to nukes, that is ready to reinstitute your tax-funded payments for terror murders of Israelis, that has its projected president neck-deep in corruption and client connection with the true enemies of the US—it is now on the verge of gaining unlimited power. A one-party totalitarian state, partnered with its benevolent creditor, Communist China. No Latin needed.
Hi, Michael.
ReplyDeleteClicking aimlessly through some old bookmarks of mine, I came across your blog, only to find this new post from yesterday.
I know the readership here is small, but that doesn't mean we can't have an interesting discussion, even if it's just a few of us. In all likelihood, the coziness of the audience will hopefully allow for a more meaningful dialogue.
Out of the gate, I have to say that I'm legitimately surprised to hear you parroting conspiracy-minded talking points that are, as far as I'm aware, entirely unscientific. You're a scientist, after all; so that's why I'm going to ask you to cite some sources! To wit, please give me (credible) reasons to believe that this virus, which affected China severely, as well as most of the world, is a "Chinese biological attack." I'm *not* asking for you to tell me why the Communist Party might want to unleash such an attack—rather, I'm asking for evidence, whatever you can offer, that it actually was such. I'm no virologist, but I'm not aware of anything from a scientific source supporting your claim, so I'm all ears. I know that absence of evidence is not evidence of absence, but if you don't have a scientific source (or sources), you're going to have to really explain why I should believe such a severe claim.
You wrote of "Trump, who has done the maximum he could to withstand the biological attack while fighting the sabotage of Democrat governors, the posturing of know-nothing buffoons from NIH and WHO…" which surprises me. This is the same president who holds massive rallies and disparages mask-wearing, in the midst of an airborne pandemic, no? The "know-nothings" at the WHO and NIH: who are they, and what axe are they grinding? Are they just automatons who will do or say anything that's harmful to Trump? Do you have any reason I should believe that they're not doing their best to fight the disease?
-rz
I am also surprised, I think legitimately, that you can call a “meaningful dialogue” something that you start with accusing me of “parroting conspiracy-minded talking points.” Whether that is true or false, it just is not very conducive to any dialogue. Hence, before I enter into any discussion (and I may, of course, have answers to your questions), please give me (credible) reasons your insult has any foundation. Then, if you can do that, please provide credible evidence that what I wrote was incorrect—there would be then some way to proceed. To start, your statement that the virus affected China is irrelevant: this is a communist regime, for which lives matter little. Mao used to say that half or two thirds of humanity may die in a nuclear war, but capitalism will perish too and the rest will live in peace. It is also telling that internal travel was stopped in China while international travel continued, and the Party deliberately suppressed information, including physical removal of whistleblowers. I can continue how that is a biological war if it’s unclear, but I’ll wait for your apologies.
ReplyDeleteI guess, I should not hold my breath. The progressive public’s demands are never matched by their own conduct. Especially now that they may have succeeded, with Communist China’s viral assistance, in the coup d’etat they have been attempting for over three years.
Deletehttps://www.bizpacreview.com/2021/01/17/us-has-the-evidence-that-researchers-in-wuhan-lab-fell-ill-before-coronavirus-outbreak-state-dept-says-1017394/?
ReplyDeletehttps://www.bizpacreview.com/2021/05/30/bombshell-study-claims-smoking-gun-found-proving-chinese-scientists-created-covid-19-1081348
ReplyDeleteI wonder when it finally comes clear that the Wuhan work cluelessly (at best) funded by NIAID was the Chinese biological weapons program. https://redstate.com/scotthounsell/2021/06/01/breaking-wuhan-lab-funder-email-thanks-fauci-for-running-defense-on-lab-leak-theory-n389836
ReplyDeleteanother case of "post hoc" venom: https://abcnews.go.com/Politics/police-clear-lafayette-park-area-trump-hold-bible/story?id=78171712
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeletehttps://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2021/aug/23/chinese-communist-partys-covid-19-pandemic-is-amer/
ReplyDeleteOne thing not noted in the article is the collusion between the CCP and the Democrats in the US in order to depose Trump and allow Biden, a Chinese asset, to take his place. This is a more concrete motive than the desire for China to move "closer to the world’s center stage.”
https://www.bizpacreview.com/2021/09/29/ny-times-vindicates-tucker-reports-on-fbi-operatives-deeply-involved-in-jan-6-event-1141676/
ReplyDeleteWho would ever guess? https://www.wsj.com/articles/covid-19-coronavirus-lab-leak-virology-origins-pandemic-11633462827?
ReplyDelete